
Reading the front-page article in the August 17 print edition of the Indianapolis Star brought back many memories for me. The story, written by Jake Allen and John Tuohy, examines the lack of public transportation in Hamilton County, particularly in Fishers, Noblesville, Carmel, and Westfield.
While I’m glad the state’s largest newspaper chose to spotlight this long-standing issue, I found it curious that the article opens with the story of a commuter traveling from Indianapolis to Whitestown—located not in Hamilton, but Boone County.
Transit has been a recurring debate in Hamilton County. I recall that during Fishers’ first mayoral race in 2014, candidates sparred over the idea of a commuter train running downtown along the Nickel Plate rail line. At one point, Fishers even had a subsidized commuter bus into Indianapolis during major highway construction projects. The service was popular, but once the subsidy ended, gas prices stabilized, and fares rose, ridership plummeted and the bus was discontinued.
Any hope for rail service ended when the Nickel Plate tracks were removed to make way for today’s trail. Train enthusiasts fought to preserve the line, even taking their case to court, but the trail ultimately prevailed.
The Star piece raises a few important points. Cities across Indiana, many smaller than Hamilton County’s suburbs, operate local transit systems—but they rely heavily on taxpayer subsidies. Here, the notion of subsidies collides with suburban fears: that mass transit might bring crime or waste money with empty buses.
The article cites a Northwestern University professor who notes that even when buses aren’t full, transit systems can still be valuable. After all, he points out, airplanes often fly with empty seats—yet commercial air travel remains heavily subsidized.
For now, the bottom line is clear: Indiana’s wealthiest county has little appetite to fund mass transit. The ones left behind are the workers in Marion County who would gladly fill jobs in Hamilton County but have no reliable way to get there. In the end, employers lose too, struggling to fill positions that local residents cannot.
You can read the IndyStar story at this link, but you will need a subscription to access it. Once again, subscribe to your local media – if you do not, it will go away.










