

A recent claim about which Indianapolis television news operation is “number one” has sparked a public back-and-forth — and a closer look shows the answer is not as simple as it once was.
Jacob Stewart, an opinion columnist for The Indianapolis Star, recently wrote that WTHR holds the top spot in the local market. That prompted a response on social media from Angela Ganote of WXIN (Fox59), who countered that her station is actually No. 1.
So, who is right?
In today’s fragmented media environment, both sides can make a case — depending on how “number one” is defined.
Stewart’s claim is rooted in a recent Federal Communications Commission filing tied to the proposed merger between Nexstar Media Group and Tegna Inc.. Nexstar owns Fox59, while Tegna owns WTHR. The deal has been stalled by a federal court injunction, with a final ruling still pending.
That FCC filing cites Nielsen data showing WTHR ranked No. 1 overall in the Indianapolis market, with Fox59 a close second. The ranking is based on total audience share across a broad broadcast day, not a single newscast.
That distinction matters.
Television ratings are typically broken into “dayparts” — morning, midday, evening and late night — and it is common for different stations to lead in different time slots. A station may dominate mornings, for example, while another leads at 11 p.m. Without seeing those individual breakdowns, a single “No. 1” label can oversimplify the picture.
The FCC filing also suggests WTHR generates more overall revenue, another traditional indicator of market strength.
But television is no longer just television.
Digital platforms now play a major role in how audiences consume local news, and by that measure, Fox59 appears to have the edge. Publicly available web traffic estimates consistently show Fox59 drawing significantly more online visitors than its competitors, indicating a larger digital audience.
On another major platform — YouTube — the advantage shifts again. WTHR’s channel leads the Indianapolis market with roughly 385,000 subscribers, well ahead of other local stations.
The bottom line: there is no single, universally accepted measure of “number one” anymore.
On traditional broadcast ratings, the best publicly available data points to WTHR as the market leader, with Fox59 close behind. On digital platforms, particularly web traffic, Fox59 appears to hold the top spot. On YouTube, WTHR leads again.
In other words, the answer depends on which scoreboard you are using — and in today’s media landscape, there are several.