
The Fishers City Council voted 8-0 Monday night to deny a rezoning request for One Sixteen, a proposed 25-home neighborhood on East 116th Street.
The city’s planning director told the council that the updated proposal called for 25 homes. The version reviewed by the Fishers Plan Commission earlier this month called for 26.
Integra Builders sought to rezone 10.45 acres at 10401 E. 116th St., the site of an existing place of worship. The property is part of the Legends at Geist planned unit development. The builder sought a new zoning designation for One Sixteen, a neighborhood of single-family homes.
The council’s Nov. 16 decision followed a 7-0 vote by the Plan Commission on Nov. 4 to recommend denial. Several nearby residents spoke against the proposal at the commission’s public hearing.
City Councilor Pete Peterson, who also serves on the commission, said at that hearing that he opposed the brownstone-style homes proposed closest to 116th Street. He said the design would fit in downtown Fishers but was out of place at the proposed site.
The council agenda described a single public loop street and 20-foot tree preservation buffers along the east, south and west sides of the property. The plan reviewed by the commission included open space along 116th Street and a central stormwater detention area.
City planning staff supported the rezoning. The staff report said the proposal met the suburban residential designation in the Fishers 2040 comprehensive plan, which calls for two to four homes per acre.
Residents raised concerns about traffic, drainage, housing density and the preservation of mature trees at an August neighborhood meeting, according to the staff report. Written comments also raised questions about privacy and how the development would fit with surrounding neighborhoods. One resident supported the rezoning on the condition that the existing tree line next to homes along Spyglass Ridge Drive be preserved.