
At Wednesday night’s Hamilton Southeastern (HSE) School Board meeting, members will receive a first reading on proposed changes to the district’s Teacher Appreciation Grant policy. Often known as TAG grants, these awards recognize teachers for their performance. The revised policy will move to the board’s Policy Committee for further review before returning to the full board for a final vote at a later meeting.
The proposed changes are required under new Indiana legislation passed during last year’s session of the General Assembly. Many educators statewide have expressed concerns about the new approach.
Previously, TAG grants were awarded to teachers rated “effective” or “highly effective” in their performance evaluations—criteria that resulted in a broad portion of classroom teachers receiving the bonuses. Under the new law, however, no more than 20% of a district’s teaching staff may receive a TAG award. By comparison, roughly 89% of teachers statewide qualified under the previous system.
Eligibility under the new rules is tied primarily to demonstrating a “significant impact on student outcomes” based on national, state, or local assessment data. Educators in areas without standardized testing—such as special education, counseling, and the arts—have raised concerns that they may be placed at a disadvantage when competing for the limited number of grants.
While fewer teachers will receive the grants, those who do will be awarded larger amounts. Payouts under the new structure will range from $3,500 to $7,500.
The Indiana State Teachers Association (ISTA) opposed the legislation, arguing that the competitive design of the program will “sow competition and division” rather than promote the collaboration encouraged by the previous model. Local teachers’ union president Tyler Zerbe told LarryInFishers that HSE teachers generally do not support the changes.
One question remains unanswered: What happens if more than 20% of teachers in a district meet the eligibility criteria? State guidance is unclear, and some districts are reportedly considering a lottery system as a last resort.
The HSE District is now preparing to revise its policies to comply with the statewide mandate. This shift in TAG criteria was a state decision, not a local one.








